About Mike Morrell
Michael Morrell is the collaborating author, with Fr. Richard Rohr, on
The Divine Dance: The Trinity and Your Transformation. He's also the founder of Wisdom Camp, a day-retreat for mystical misfits, and a founding organizer of the justice, arts, and spirituality Wild Goose Festival.
Michael curates contemplative and community experiences, taking joy in holding space for the extraordinary transformation that can
take place at the intersection of anticipation, imagination, and radical
acceptance.
Michael is also an avid writer, publishing consultant, author coach, futurist, and curator of the book-reviewing community,
Speakeasy. His two children are growing up entirely too fast and he lives in Asheville, North Carolina.
Paraclete Press is an arm of the Community of Jesus on Cape Cod. I was a religious brother there for seven years. My father was a pastor at the Community.
During that time, I saw a great deal of emotional and physical abuse. I finally left, having been convinced by my experience that what began well had turned into a destructive, authoritative cult. Since then, I’ve stayed in close touch with other ex-members and the allegations of abuse seem to have become even worse.
The Community has a wonderful public face. They have a world-class choir (Gloriae Dei Cantores), a fine band (Spirit of America) and, of course, Paraclete Press.
I wrote to Peter about my concerns and was greatly heartened that he took them seriously. As someone who finds the Emerging Church movement very exciting, I would hate to see leaders in the movement be deceived.
Hal Helms
I do business with Paraclete Press as a retailer. I know several authors who write for them and several of their employees. I really don’t know that much about the Community of Jesus, just like I don’t know that much about the owners of most of the other publishers I do business with. I do know that most if not all faith communities experience brokenness and sin (hey, I’m a Roman Catholic, remember!), so it does not surprise me that some people have had bad experiences with that community. Obviously, to the extent that this community is dysfunctional, I hope and pray that accountability, repentance and reconciliation will win out over continued abuse and misconduct.
Hal Helms seems to be suggesting that we shouldn’t do business with Paraclete because of its ties to the Community of Jesus. While I respect Mr. Helm’s opinion, I also know that the line separating “cult” from “messy imperfect community trying to do the best it can and sometimes failing spectacularly” is very blurry indeed. Like Peter Rollins, I’m willing to take Helm’s allegations seriously, while also choosing to reserve judgment until I had more comprehensive information, both pro and con, on which to base my opinion. After all, if I stopped doing business with every publisher which had controversial owners, I’d probably have a pretty empty bookstore.
In reference to the quote below…Paraclete does not have ties to a destructive cult – it is owned by them. This is not a messy imperfect community. It is a destructive cult. The leader Betty Pugsley has lied repeatedly. My parents were oblate members for 40 years and they caused much destruction to our family with their abuse and teachings. I understand that all groups have dark parts. But when the dark part is the leadership and the leadership has not apologized or changed its ways, then it is time to do the right thing and break off ties.
“Hal Helms seems to be suggesting that we shouldn’t do business with Paraclete because of its ties to the Community of Jesus. While I respect Mr. Helm’s opinion, I also know that the line separating “cult” from “messy imperfect community trying to do the best it can and sometimes failing spectacularly” is very blurry indeed. Like Peter Rollins, I’m willing to take Helm’s allegations seriously, while also choosing to reserve judgment until I had more comprehensive information, both pro and con, on which to base my opinion. After all, if I stopped doing business with every publisher which had controversial owners, I’d probably have a pretty empty bookstore.”
Thank you – all three of you – for weighing in.